Self-Acceptance and Authentic Relational Connection

I have low self-esteem.  I feel both burdened and annoyed by this.  And, somehow, acknowledging that I don't feel very good about myself actually makes me feel worse about myself.  I peruse Google for tips on how to create healthy self-esteem, and for information on the emotional causes of self-sabotage.  I know there's no quick-fix when it comes to loving yourself; it's a slow and steady process that comes with time, healing, and probably help.  Sometimes I wonder how much of our sense of self-worth is affected by our language; because I have diseases, do I then see myself as inherently diseased?  I understand the disease label as an indicator of functioning that differs from "normal," but what is normal anyway?  And if the word disease didn't hold so many connotations of abnormality and brokenness, would the various days of my diagnoses have brought such sadness and disappointment?

Last night, I found an article that discusses our use of addictive behaviors to deal with loneliness and low self-esteem.  The author focuses in particular on eating, but the ideas extend to any practices that distract us from our own emotional turmoil, namely loneliness.

When you’re chronically lonely, just being around other people doesn’t fix it.  You can be married and lonely; you can be lonely in a crowd.  If you’re chronically lonely, what you lack is authentic connections with other human beings, and generally that’s because you block these connections by not sharing your authentic self.  Why?

People who are chronically lonely almost always have as a core problem that they don’t like themselves very much. The give-away is that they generally find it almost unbearable to be alone--especially at night when the distractions of the day are over and it’s quiet.  They may even dread turning off the light to go to sleep at night, and procrastinate on that.

Chronically lonely people often have an almost phobic reaction to being by themselves.  It feels like falling down a black hole--an awful "dust in the wind" feeling of utter emptiness and alienation from everything and everyone, as though you’re the only person on the planet.  If you live alone, you probably avoid going home at night because you can’t bear to be home alone with that feeling.  You call it loneliness, but it’s really something else.  It’s the horrors; it’s existential alienation.  The Big Empty.

Quiet evenings alone are often when emotional eaters binge, perhaps numbing out in front of the TV.  They may stay awake until so late that they practically drop from exhaustion, or they may use alcohol to go to sleep so they don’t have to experience their own thoughts lying in bed in the dark.

What is this about?  If you can’t bear to be by yourself, it essentially means you can’t bear yourself--you can’t bear your own company, you can’t bear the experience of being "you".  That is a huge problem, and it’s also a big block to developing healthy relationships.  That’s why it goes along with loneliness and people call it loneliness, but it’s not exactly the same as loneliness.

You can’t stand your own company without distractions because you don’t like yourself.  And because you don’t like yourself, you assume no one else will like you either, causing you to shun social contact, making you lonely.

Sheryl Canter argues that the only solution to chronic loneliness is authentic human connection, or finding people who accept and love you in your entirety--which I don't think can be done until we accept and love ourselves and truly believe we deserve acceptance and love.

The only thing that cures loneliness is authentic human connection.  That means allowing another to see you for who you really are and experiencing their acceptance, and seeing another for who they really are and accepting them.

If you don’t like yourself much, it can be scary to let others see the real you.  Your impulse will be to hide your real thoughts and feelings under the mistaken notion that the real you is unacceptable and will be rejected.  But you’ve got to get past this and take the risk because if you never let anyone see you, you will stay lonely.

My lack of self-love is not a new realization, and I have discussed it openly in the past.  However, this week was the first time that I allowed my low self-esteem to affect my relationships with other people--and drawing people into my inner-turmoil is not something I want or hope to do.  Primarily, I don't want to hurt the people I care about.  And, equally important, I don't want my sense of self-worth to hinge on a relationship with anyone, because: 1.) humans are imperfect, and eventually I will be disappointed; 2.) that is an unfair amount of pressure and an unrealistic expectation to place on an individual.

Several years ago, I had a vision of myself carrying around my heart in my hand, trying to pass it along to anyone who would take it.  In many ways, I think I still do that, desperately seeking a person who will see me holistically and love every part of me.  I know that approval, affirmation, and acceptance need to come from my relationship with God first and foremost.  Sometimes I am so overwhelmed by my own neediness and sense of waywardness.  He promises to draw near to me as I attempt to draw near Him, and that truth is my only comfort.

Psalm 139: 1-5, 16 (CEB)
"Lord, you have examined me.

You know me.

You know when I sit down and when I stand up.

Even from far away, you comprehend my plans.
You study my traveling and resting.
You are thoroughly familiar with all my ways.
There isn’t a word on my tongue, Lord,
that you don’t already know completely.
You surround me--front and back.
You put your hand on me.
Your eyes saw my embryo,

and on your scroll every day was written that was being formed for me,

before any one of them had yet happened."

The Imagined Life vs. Real Life

I've struggled to live in the present for probably half my life.  Sometime during high school, as childhood came to an end and I propelled towards adulthood, all that demanded my attention seemed to exist in the future: test scores, grades, college applications, a bachelor's degree, a first job.  We were trained to do everything for the sake of what would eventually come, and so I think in some ways we were conditioned not to live in the moment, but instead to always be moving forward and looking to the next thing, the bigger thing, the better thing.

This week I've experienced a tumult of emotions, which I blame in large part on a mix-up at my local pharmacy.  I was unknowingly given the wrong thyroid medication last Monday, and for most of the week I experienced severe mood swings; they caused such a marked change in my disposition that I eventually had the intuitive sense to check the imprint on my hormone tablets, and thus uncovered the error.  It was emotionally exhausting, to say the least, but in combination with beginning to read Steven Pressfield's The War of Art last weekend, I've had some time to thoughtfully consider where I am in life and the direction in which I am and/or hope to be moving.

For the past several years, living an imagined life has been my default.  I think I've encountered so much pain during this second half of my life that I cope by dwelling in the land of imagination.  INFJs are naturally future-focused as it is, so I'm likely hard-wired to use daydreams as a sort of coping mechanism.  I've constructed fantasies about where I'll live, what I'll do, what I'll have, who I'll be with.  I've created imaginary depth in relationships with people I actually know, and dreamed of pretend scenarios that some part of me hoped would come true, if only to take me away from the life that I actually know.

Clearly, using imagination as a means of escape just signals a larger issue of not wanting to deal with my reality, the here-and-now.  Perhaps my imagination has bred a sort of hope that has made the pain of disease and illness bearable.  If that's the case, I can't be too hard on myself for finding a way of moving forward in what have been the most difficult years of my life.  At the same time, living so much in fantasy not only keeps us from progressing, but prevents us from appreciating the people and circumstances that exist in a given moment in time and space.  Incidentally, focusing on an imagined future has actually prevented me from advancing in life.  Now that I think about it, I suppose that I haven't wanted to move forward, as I'm sure that in many ways I maintain a fear about what is to come.  Will there be more pain?  Disappointment?  Suffering?  Disease?  Hopes squashed?  Imagining a future has given me a sense of control over the terrifying unknown.

What is to be done about chronic disappointment?  Normally I would say that a person has too many expectations.  I thought it was fair for a person to assume s/he would experience good health, true love, and vocational fulfillment, but now I realize that any expectation is already too many.  We can't know what life will bring us, what will be our assigned portion and cup.  I have handed my security over to dreams and fantasies, when I should have been entrusting my security to God.  Isn't it like us to trust our own imaginations over the sovereignty and loving-kindness of a divine and all-good Creator?  I find myself proving over and over that I lack trust and faith in God.  Fortunately, He continues to be good and loving and all-knowing whether or not I believe Him to be so.

I often say that I wish I trusted Him more.  And I do.  But more than that, I think I wish I knew Him more.  Because if I truly knew Him, I don't think I'd be afraid of Him.  Because I don't think I'm as afraid of entrusting my future to someone else as much as I am entrusting it to God.  Because when I entrust my future to God, it feels like I am inviting more pain and disappointment and suffering and disease and squashed hopes.  I know I'm partly jaded because of misfortune, but hasn't it been the very hand of God that has allowed my life to go on like this up until now?  And isn't it up to His sovereign hand what the outcome of my life will be in the future?  I wish I could say that I honestly believe that He uses all of our life experiences for our own benefit.  But it's difficult to truly trust that the enormity of my pain and disappointment has been a blessing rather than a curse.

It would be selfish and ungrateful for me to ignore the great amount of blessings in my life, from living in a beautiful location in a beautiful home, to having a loving and supportive family; from being the dog-mom to a most handsome miniature schnauzer, to having a secure job that I enjoy enough on most days to keep me going back; from having a master's-level education, to having access to healthy food and a healthy lifestyle.  When I consider the struggles of people around the world, mine seem so small.  But, my emotions are as they are, and because so much of my pain has been internal, sometimes the evidence of external blessings is clouded.

And I've arrived at this point in my writing without any conclusions.  Except that I know I want to be more present in my life, in the here-and-now.  And I do still have hopes for the future.  And if I am going to make an effort to stop living an imagined life, that means all I can do is entrust the outcome of my life to God.  And my one true future hope is this: that He will fulfill His promise to do more in my life than I am capable of hoping for or imagining.  My hope is to truly internalize, despite whatever circumstances I encounter, His divine goodness and love for me.

Upon further contemplation, I realize that my greatest gift as of late is vision for the future.  Not that God has imparted me with specifics on where or what or who, but I feel deeply drawn (perhaps called) in a direction.  And I don't think I would be moving in this direction had it not been for the very experiences I've endured.  I have always said that my one desire in life is to help people.  Now it is my desire to see my experiences, particularly the painful ones, act as the platform for my destiny and purpose.  If I am a lump of clay in the process of being made into some useful piece of pottery, then my trials are the tools that are shaping the form I am to become.  I believe that my pain is deeply tied to God's designation for my life, and so I can see now how my disappointments will actually lead me to be a truer, more authentic version of myself--the divinely-ordained version.  Ultimately, I cling to the belief that my pain will be the most profound source of my abiding joy.

Disheveled: Becoming “Post-Evangelical”

The main title for this post came to me as I sat in my bedroom in momentary silence, reflecting on the current state of my life. It was the one word that popped into my head as I stared at my messy closet and the shelved books I had just sorted through. My collection of books has always acted as a sort of barometer for where I’m at and what I’m interested in. In the past, the shelves were brimming with titles related to theology, Ethnic Studies, Christian romance, nutrition, classics. Over the years, I whittled down my number of books in hopes of abating a semi-addiction to buying reading material from Amazon. The books I knew I wouldn’t read, I parted with, and I refused to allow myself to purchase anything new until after the books on my shelves were read.

Since that first weeding through the books, my collection has seemed to shrink rather than grow. Or, perhaps the contents--the themes and topics--have merely changed so vastly that it seems shrunken, when in fact it’s not the number of books that’s been depleted but my sense of faith.

As I was examining the spines of books still in my possession, I came upon my university yearbook. The summer before I left for college, freshmen had the opportunity to send in copies of their senior photos along with a selection of two interests from a form that listed pre-determined activities and fields. I still remember when I received this notice and decided to participate. There was no option for Jesus or faith, and so I chose the write-in option at the bottom and inscribed “Christianity” on the blank line. At that time, it was very important to me that people knew what I was about. In my mind, knowing that I was a Christian was more important for people than knowing my name, or major, or how I spent my weekends (although, I could have come up with a way to link all of those things back to the fact that I’m a Christian). Even during my first phone call with the dorm roommate I was paired with, I openly talked about my faith and the depth of its importance to me.

Along with the yearbook, I found some old books on practical spirituality that I no longer want to keep. They seem to be the last bit of proof that I was once evangelical. Now, I make that claim with some hesitation, as I don’t know that I will ever be entirely “post-evangelical.” My upbringing in the church and experiences doing ministry around the world have created deep roots that I don’t know will ever really die off or be able to be pulled out. But I know that my faith is not the same as it once was; it seems to have become disheveled.

I was contemplating my feelings towards the church, and the only thoughts I can ever really come up with are that I have been deeply wounded. But as I sat and considered those words, it occurred to me that God and the church are not one in the same. God has not wounded me, but the church, and more specifically Christians in the church, have wounded me. And it’s not even necessarily specific people or churches or occurrences, but it is in large part the ideas and ideals I was imparted with so that I feel that I was in some ways recklessly (though the intention was not reckless) led to believe things that actually did more harm than good. Rachel Held Evans articulated my own sentiments beautifully:

“When you grow up believing that your religious worldview contains the key to absolute truth and provides an answer to every question, you never really get over the disappointment of learning that it doesn't...Like it or not, our religious traditions help forge our identities. The great challenge...is to hold every piece of my faith experience in love, even the broken bits, even the parts that still cut my hands and make them bleed. We are all post-something. We are all caught between who we once were and who we will be, the ghosts of past certainties gripping at our ankles. There’s no just getting over it. There’s no easy moving on.”

I haven’t regularly attended church in over two years, mostly because I don’t really know where I belong, but also because I needed space. My life was so hyper-focused for so many years on my participation in church and evangelical activities that I lost my sense of self. I would use the justification that we are to sacrifice ourselves for the cause of the cross and a crucified Savior. However, I think that my lifestyle was more representative of a codependent relationship and sense of fear than anything else. I was terrified of somehow losing my faith that my entire life became based on being engaged and a leader in as many Christian organizations and opportunities as I could possibly be involved with. In some ways, I admire that kind of dedication and commitment. At the same time, I had no idea who I was.

As my 20s quickly come to a close, I’ve been reflecting a lot lately on the amount of growth and change I’ve experienced during the past decade. I feel that every year since I first left for college has been one of pivotal self-discovery, particularly my year in China and those following. I can thank my time in college for providing me with the tools to think critically. It all started with ideas related to social justice. The frameworks for thinking that I learned in my Ethnic Studies classes began to shape how I viewed other fields, including Christianity. As justice for the oppressed grew in importance to me, I began to see my political ideals aligning with Liberalism. And because I had grown up believing that Christians were automatically Republicans, I had to begin to reconsider my faith and how I could possibly reconcile belief in Jesus and His message with Democratic ideologies.

I don’t consider myself to be a Democrat, but I merely point out this example to mark the first moment of the dishevelment of my faith. It was that one small reconsideration that has led me to become more critical in my thinking about Christianity, in relation to people groups, sexuality, church attendance, relationships, purpose, and beyond. I know that there are many circles and branches of Christianity throughout the world, but it’s difficult not to feel like you’re amidst a divorce from evangelicalism and looking to remarry a new Christianity. And perhaps that’s why I’ve taken a break from church for so long; I’ve been mourning the loss of a Christianity that was as formative as it was painful for me.

As I lay the on carpet in my bedroom and stared at my ceiling, all I could think about was the fact that God is with me and will continue to go with me--no matter the state of my heart or circumstances. And I know I will never fully understand Him in this life, and I know that I will often feel disappointed by the church and by Christians; but I also know that He is not done with me yet. He has appointed me my portion and my cup, and as much as I’ve faced disappointments and trials and pain, I truly believe that I am part of a much larger purpose and story. I just hope that those disappointments and those trials and that pain shape me to be more compassionate and Christ-like in my life. And even when I don’t know what label to use when it comes to talking about my faith, I pray my eyes will ever be fixed on Jesus and all that He was and all that He stands for and spoke about. God is bigger than our interpretations and ideas and labels and debates and churches.